How-to Make Plantain Tortillas | Tasty Yummies Paleo Meal Prep Recipes (2024)

How-to Make Plantain Tortillas | Tasty Yummies Paleo Meal Prep Recipes (2)

Whether you to avoid consuming corn and grains because have an allergy/intolerance or maybe you just prefer to limit how often you eat them, either way we all know this makes eating Mexican food a challenge. I am next to certain this life isn’t worth living without tacos – I’m just sayin’. OK that may be a bit dramatic, but I for one don’t actually love the idea of never having a taco again, just because I want to make healthier choices.

With Cinco de Mayo and several trips to Mexico falling within a one-month period, tacos have definitely been on my mind and in my dreams! I decided rather than cry while everyone around me was indulging in all the tacos, I used this as inspiration to come up with an alternative.

Plantain tortillas are certainly not something I invented, I have seen plenty of adaptations, some call for eggs, some use the plantains uncooked. I have played around with many variations, but these seem to be what works best for me (lightly adapted from this recipe). The key is green plantains. The greens ones are starchy and less sweet than the yellow. For my money, these produce the most authentic tortillas. I also recommend cooking them first, it softens them and when you add some water the mixture feels just the way traditional masa feels when making homemade tortillas.

There are a few steps here, but they are well worth it, you’ll think so too, especially as you are enjoying epic tacos. Plus you can make the tortillas ahead of time, store in the fridge and cook up anytime within 3 days, or so.

I find adding the fresh lime zest to really tone down any sweetness and bring out the traditional tortilla vibes. I have also been known to add a pinch or two of chile powder or garlic powder, for extra flavor.

Let’s get to it…

How-to Make Plantain Tortillas

How-to Make Plantain Tortillas | Tasty Yummies Paleo Meal Prep Recipes (3)

Start with 4 green plantains or about 2 1/2 lbs.

How-to Make Plantain Tortillas | Tasty Yummies Paleo Meal Prep Recipes (4)
How-to Make Plantain Tortillas | Tasty Yummies Paleo Meal Prep Recipes (5)
Cut the ends off and cut the plantain into 3-inch pieces. You can leave the peel on.
(Tip: cut a thin slice into the peel on one side, this makes removing the peel later, super easy)

How-to Make Plantain Tortillas | Tasty Yummies Paleo Meal Prep Recipes (6)

Add the plantains to a large pot and cover with water. Bring to a boil and then boil for 15-20 minutes, until the plantains are soft and tender, but not mushy.

How-to Make Plantain Tortillas | Tasty Yummies Paleo Meal Prep Recipes (7)

Drain the plantains. Once cool enough to handle, peel the skin off.

How-to Make Plantain Tortillas | Tasty Yummies Paleo Meal Prep Recipes (8)
How-to Make Plantain Tortillas | Tasty Yummies Paleo Meal Prep Recipes (9)

Add the plantains to a large bowl and start mashing. You can use a potato masher, a fork or you can add to your food processor. I always do this by hand with a potato masher. Keep going until most of the lumps are gone and it’s nice and pliable. Add lime zest, salt and a small amount of water, as needed. I usually add around 1/4 cup or so, total. But go a little at a time, mash it up and then see if you need more.

How-to Make Plantain Tortillas | Tasty Yummies Paleo Meal Prep Recipes (10)
How-to Make Plantain Tortillas | Tasty Yummies Paleo Meal Prep Recipes (11)

You’ll know the mixture is good when you can form it easily into small balls or one large ball of the dough.

How-to Make Plantain Tortillas | Tasty Yummies Paleo Meal Prep Recipes (12)

Using your hands, roll the dough into approximately 2-inch balls.

How-to Make Plantain Tortillas | Tasty Yummies Paleo Meal Prep Recipes (13)

Place the ball between two sheets of plastic wrap (I use a large ziplock bag with the edges and the top cut off) and on your tortilla press. (Without the plastic it can stick to the press). Press out your tortillas.

How-to Make Plantain Tortillas | Tasty Yummies Paleo Meal Prep Recipes (14)

Slowly and carefully peel off the plastic and place the tortillas onto a parchment paper lined baking sheet or cooling rack. Dampen your fingers and mend any tears that may happen and don’t freak, they don’t have to be perfect. Continue until all the dough is gone. I use a baking pan and just continue layering parchment paper on top, adding another layer of tortillas and this is a greatoptionfor storing. The uncooked tortillas will keep, covered well (cover the pan well, with plastic wrap) in the refrigeratorfor up to 3 days. I am sure they could also be frozen, but mine never make it that long.

How-to Make Plantain Tortillas | Tasty Yummies Paleo Meal Prep Recipes (15)
To cook: heat a non-stick pan OR seasoned cast iron skillet over a medium heat. If your cast iron skillet isn’t well seasoned, add a very, very small amount of oil and rub it in well. We just don’t want the tortillas to stick, but we don’t want to fry them either. Heat for about 2 to 3 minutes on the first side until lightly browned, carefully flip and heat the other side. You want the tortilla to be barely browned, cooked and still pliable but not crispy. Let cool a minute or two and then load up with your ingredients.

Enjoy as you would any other tortilla.

How-to Make Plantain Tortillas | Tasty Yummies Paleo Meal Prep Recipes (16)

[print_this]Plantain Tortillas
makes approximately 15-18 tortillas

  • 4 plantains, about 2.5 lbs
  • 1/4 teaspoon fine sea salt
  • zest from 1 lime
  • water, as needed – probably around 1/4 cup

Cut the ends off and cut the plantain into 3-inch pieces. You can leave the peel on. (tip: cut a thin slice into the peel on one side, this makes removing the peel later, super easy)

Add the plantains to a large pot and cover with water. Bring to a boil and then boil for 15-20 minutes, until the plantains are soft, but not mushy.

Drain the plantains. Once cool enough to handle, peel the skin off.

Add the plantains to a large bowl and start mashing. You can use a potato masher, a fork or you can add to your food processor. I always do this by hand with a potato masher. Keep going until most of the lumps are gone. Add lime zest, salt and a small amount of water, as needed. I usually add around 1/4 cup or so, total. But go a little at a time, mash it up and then see if you need more.

You’ll know the mixture is good when you can form it easily into small balls or one large ball of the dough.

Using your hands roll the dough into approximately 2-inch balls.

Place the ball between two sheets of plastic wrap (I use a large ziplock bag with the edges and the top cut off) and on your tortilla press. Press out your tortillas.

Slowly and carefully peel off the plastic and place the tortillas onto a parchment paper lined baking sheet or cooling rack. Dampen your fingers and mend any tears that may happen and don’t freak, they don’t have to be perfect. Continue until all the dough is gone. I use a baking pan and just continue layering parchment paper on top, adding another layer of tortillas and this is a greatoptionfor storing. The uncooked tortillas will keep, covered well (cover the pan well, with plastic wrap) in the refrigeratorfor up to 3 days. I am sure they could also be frozen, but mine never make it that long.

To Cook the Tortillas: heat a non-stick pan OR seasoned cast iron skillet over a medium heat. If your cast iron skillet isn’t well seasoned, add a very, very small amount of oil and rub it in well. We just don’t want the tortillas to stick, but we don’t want to fry them either. Heat for 2 to 3 minutes on the first side, carefully flip and heat the other side. You want the tortilla to be barely browned, cooked and still pliable. Be careful not to burn. Let cool a minute or two and then load up with your ingredients.

Enjoy as you would any other tortilla. Eat ALL the tacos, make enchiladas or cut these into triangles, fry them up and make chips.

NOTES: I haven’t yet tried making these without the tortilla press. It’s possible you could place the dough balls between two sheets of parchment paper and roll it out with a rolling pin, but I would highly suggest you just buy a tortilla press. It’s cheap and it lasts forever.

Try adding a pinch or two of chile powder or garlic powder, for extra flavor.

[/print_this]

How-to Make Plantain Tortillas | Tasty Yummies Paleo Meal Prep Recipes (17)

How-to Make Plantain Tortillas | Tasty Yummies Paleo Meal Prep Recipes (2024)

FAQs

How do you keep homemade tortillas fresh? ›

Wait for the tortillas to cool completely before storing them. Stack the tortillas on top of each other and wrap them tightly in aluminum foil or plastic wrap. Place the wrapped tortillas in an airtight container or resealable plastic bag. Store the tortillas at room temperature for up to 2 days.

Can you freeze tortillas to keep them fresh? ›

Tortillas are one of the most freezer-friendly baked goods out there: As long as they're properly wrapped, they'll maintain their flavor and texture excellently for up to 6 months. Even better, they're easy and speedy to defrost once you're ready to use them.

Can you make homemade tortillas ahead of time? ›

If you want to make the tortillas ahead, they can be kept, wrapped in a clean kitchen towel or cloth, at room temperature.

What are 3 ways to warm up the tortillas? ›

Keep reading to find out the best methods to heat your Mi Rancho tortillas.
  1. Over an open flame. This task may sound daunting to many, but it's quite easy and takes only seconds. ...
  2. On a hot iron cast skillet (a Comal) This is my personal favorite way to heat up both flour and corn tortillas. ...
  3. In the oven.

Can you eat corn tortillas without warming them up? ›

It's essential to warm corn tortillas before eating them because the heat coaxes out their fresh, earthy flavors. Applying heat to tortillas also makes them more pliable and less likely to break or tear when filled with proteins and other hearty fillings.

Why do my flour tortillas crack when I roll them? ›

A common problem with homemade tortillas is cracked and jagged edges, a surefire sign that the dough needs more water. You can prevent cracked tortillas by pressing a test tortilla before you roll the rest of the dough into balls.

Why do my homemade tortillas fall apart? ›

If your dough is hard to manage (it falls apart) when you try to roll it into small balls or it cracks when you press it, then it's too dry. Test this by checking the edges of your pressed raw tortillas. If they're jagged and crackly, the dough lacks a bit of moisture.

Why are my tortillas breaking when I roll them? ›

Dryness, stiffness, and heat — oh my!

If you've made your tortilla dough earlier in the day and are storing it in the fridge, the cold dough will be drier and stiffer — two surefire issues that will lead to cracking. Even non-glutinous doughs get stretchier as they warm.

How do you store homemade tortillas long term? ›

For homemade corn tortillas, you can either refrigerate them and they will last 2–3 weeks or freeze them and thaw them at room temperature or in the fridge.

How long do homemade tortillas stay fresh? ›

Homemade tortillas, which will obviously not be in a tortilla packet, will only last around 2-3 days in the cupboard. However, they last up to a week in the refrigerator and much longer in the freezer, so why not make your own tortillas and store them away for when the burrito craving hits!

How do you keep homemade flour tortillas from getting hard? ›

Transfer cooked tortillas into tortilla warmer, or wrap in a kitchen towel, or in a closed paper towel lined container. This will make them soft and pliable. Wipe any excess flour off the skillet bottom in between cooking tortillas to prevent burnt residue.

How do you store tortillas so they don't go bad? ›

storebought might go bad faster. For the most part, though, refrigerating your tortillas once the package is open can protect them from mold and bacteria for longer. This means less food waste and more tacos in your life…

Top Articles
Latest Posts
Article information

Author: Dong Thiel

Last Updated:

Views: 5830

Rating: 4.9 / 5 (79 voted)

Reviews: 86% of readers found this page helpful

Author information

Name: Dong Thiel

Birthday: 2001-07-14

Address: 2865 Kasha Unions, West Corrinne, AK 05708-1071

Phone: +3512198379449

Job: Design Planner

Hobby: Graffiti, Foreign language learning, Gambling, Metalworking, Rowing, Sculling, Sewing

Introduction: My name is Dong Thiel, I am a brainy, happy, tasty, lively, splendid, talented, cooperative person who loves writing and wants to share my knowledge and understanding with you.